It’s 10:30 p.m., you’re hungry, and your usual spots have already closed. On the Upper West Side, late-night food options can feel limited—which is what makes Olde City worth bookmarking.
The Amsterdam Avenue cheesesteak spot, which opened late last year at 201 Amsterdam Avenue (between West 69th and 70th Streets), is open daily from 11 a.m. to midnight. That’s seven days a week, no exceptions—making it one of the neighborhood’s most reliable options for a post-movie bite, a late dinner after a long day, or that 11 p.m. craving you didn’t see coming.
Founded by Philly native Evan Stein, who’s been serving authentic cheesesteaks in New York since 2005, Olde City does the classics right: tender shaved steak or chicken on handmade bread delivered fresh and warmed in-house, with your choice of cheese. The menu also includes wings, Philly pretzels, Italian fries, roast pork sandwiches loaded with homemade broccoli rabe and Cooper Sharp American, and their brand-new pork roll fries, smothered in cheese whiz and topped with a crispy pork roll (a Philly staple).
Roast Pork Special
Pork Roll Fries
Whether you’re stopping in on your way home or ordering pickup online, Olde City makes it easy—and right now, you can use code UWS10 for 10% off in-store or online pickup orders at loveoldecity.com.
