Free Upper West Side News, Delivered To Your Inbox
When a tabby cat began wandering the stairwell of a small walk-up in the West 80s late last month, no one knew where he came from. But within days, neighbors across the building had organized an impromptu rescue effort — leaving out food, posting handwritten signs, and ultimately connecting the cat with a foster home — all without ever being asked.
Advertisement
The story began around March 23, when workers arrived to clean out the apartment of a third-floor resident who had recently passed away. The man’s partner had died about two years earlier, and neighbors say he had no children or other known family connections. He did, however, have two cats.One of the cats was found inside the apartment and brought to a city shelter. But the other — a brown tabby with green-gold eyes — slipped out unnoticed and spent the better part of a week roaming the building’s hallways.
“He just started showing up outside my apartment,” said Isabel, a second-floor resident and law student who is now fostering the cat. “I was leaving for class one morning and he was right outside my door.”
By the time Isabel spotted him, a neighbor had already taped a handwritten sign in the lobby: “IS ANYONE MISSING A CAT? THERE IS A LOST…” with a photo attached. That first note kicked off what became a building-wide bulletin board conversation, with residents signing updates by apartment number.
Someone on each floor set up a small station for the cat in the stairwell — a bed here, dry food there. Isabel put out wet food. Notes kept appearing. A resident on the third floor took the cat in temporarily, brought him to a vet, and contacted Big Apple Cats, a rescue organization, for help. “The cat is happy and in temporary housing at 3D,” read a handwritten update posted on March 31. “Thank you to everyone for your community spirit.”
Advertisement
Another neighbor identified the cat’s likely owner — the third-floor resident who had passed — and shared that one of his cats had been on cancer medication. That detail added a layer of sadness to the story: the cat brought to the city shelter turned out to be the sick one, and had been euthanized.The surviving cat, however, was given a name: Eli, after Eli Zabar — “to keep it local,” as one of the posted notes explained.
Kelly from Big Apple Cats helped piece together the full picture, tracking down the building’s super, who connected her with the company that had cleaned out the apartment, which in turn led her to the shelter. “Kelly’s incredible,” Isabel said. “She did really fantastic work.”
When the rescue put out a call for a longer-term foster, Isabel stepped up. “He truly showed up on my doorstep,” she said. “It felt like fate.”
Isabel, who grew up with cats and had been hoping to foster for a while, says Eli has settled into her apartment. She plans to foster him until someone adopts him — but if no one does before she graduates from law school, she hopes to adopt him herself.
Have a news tip? Send it to us here!
