San Francisco Killed New York Food Delivery

Matthew Elefant is a husband, father of three, and 20-year resident of the Upper West Side who spends much of his free time in Central Park with his family.

New York used to feed you. Not in the way cities talk about food now — the curated, the artisanal, the nine-dollar delivery fee to bring you something from four blocks away. I mean it fed you the way a city feeds people who actually live there. Cheaply. Reliably. Without making you feel like a tourist in your own neighborhood.

Advertisement

This was a system built by neighborhoods, run on memory and mutual obligation, and it worked so well that nobody thought to write it down. Which is how the people who destroyed it were able to convince everyone it had never really existed.

It existed. I was there.

There was a Chinese restaurant on the Upper West Side — Amsterdam Avenue, somewhere in the Seventies — and I couldn’t tell you its name, which tells you everything about how certain I was that it would always be there. You called them on the phone. An actual phone, bolted to the kitchen wall, with a cord that barely reached the counter. You dialed from memory, because you had the number memorized, the way people used to memorize things that mattered.

She picked up on the first ring, already yelling: “L5, sauce on the side?” You said yeah. She hung up. And before your hand had left the receiver — I mean this literally — the doorbell rang.

I know how that sounds. But I was there. There is a word for this kind of thing. The word is civilization.

ALSO READ: Remembering Columbus Avenue’s Museum Cafe

The man at the door was not a stranger. He worked at the restaurant. He knew you. He knew which buzzer in your building didn’t work and came around the side. He knew the woman in 5C got her order every Tuesday and could use a container of milk, so he brought one. He knew I smoked, and sometimes — not always, but sometimes — there was a pack tucked into the bag. This wasn’t charity. It was a deal: a direct, human, nobody-taking-a-cut arrangement between two people who had figured each other out over months of Tuesday nights. The restaurant sent him — not a platform, not an algorithm. The people who cooked your food and knew your order sent someone they trusted into your building, because that’s how you took care of the people who took care of you.

Now let me tell you about the drawer.

Advertisement

Every New Yorker had one. Not a drawer — THE drawer. You knew exactly which one. In most cities, that drawer holds silverware. In New York, it held menus. That was its entire purpose: sacred, dedicated, understood by everyone without anyone ever having to say so. And people were proud of theirs. You’d go to a friend’s apartment — same neighborhood, three blocks away — and before you’d taken your coat off, someone said: check out my drawer. And you looked, because it meant something. How deep was it? How many cuisines? Did they have the good Thai place on 82nd? The dim sum spot nobody knew about yet?

Then the trading would start. Menus like baseball cards: I’ll give you the Szechuan place on 75th if you give me that Thai menu. Deal — but I want the back number, too, the one you call when the main line is busy. The back number is not part of this negotiation. Nobody wrote any of this down. It lived in drawers and heads, passed between neighbors like something valuable — because it was. It was a library. It was a map. It was proof you lived here, really lived here; every grease stain a timestamp, every folded corner a Tuesday night you’d rather not fully account for.

ALSO READ: In Awe of Divine Cheesecake: Remembering Miss Grimble’s Bakery

I knew people with binders. Actual binders, labeled by cuisine, menus sleeved in plastic. At the time I thought they were insane. Now I think they were the only sane ones. They were archivists, preserving something that was about to disappear without knowing it. The menus themselves were works of art — not good art, but better than good art. Printed on paper that felt slightly damp, in colors that had no business appearing together. Fourteen fonts, minimum. Clip art of a steaming bowl. The restaurant’s name rendered in a typeface that suggested either Chinese antiquity or a 1987 laser printer, and sometimes both simultaneously. Completely illegible. Absolutely perfect.

And yet, at the exact same moment that we loved these menus — collected them, showed them off — half of us had a sign on our front door that said two words: NO MENU. Both things were true, simultaneously. That was also New York.

The signs never worked, and here is why: the restaurants weren’t littering. They were auditioning. Every menu shoved under your door was a bid for a slot in the drawer. That was the whole game. Get in the drawer, get in the rotation, get the Tuesday-night call. There was no Yelp, no algorithm, no sponsored placement. There was only the drawer, and if your menu wasn’t in it, you didn’t exist. So you sent a man out with two hundred menus and a complete indifference to the NO MENU signs, because the stakes were too high to be polite. I was annoyed by this at the time. I want to be honest about that. I used to crouch down and gather them up and think: does nobody read anything in this city anymore? I would give anything to come home to a pile of menus on my floor tonight. I would read every single one.

Advertisement

You know what killed it? Stanford graduates, in a conference room, over a working lunch nobody ate. They looked at the whole system — the woman who knew your order, the man who knew your building, the drawer, the menus, the whole living, breathing, slightly greasy ecosystem of it — and they saw a problem. They saw inefficiency. They saw an opportunity to insert themselves between the restaurant and the customer and extract value from the gap. They were not wrong about the opportunity. But they were completely wrong about what the system was for.

TAKE OUR QUIZ: “What Used To Be Here?” Volume 9

The system was not for efficiency. It was for the woman who remembered your sauce on the side. For the man who knew which buzzer worked. For the old woman in 5C and her Tuesday milk. For the restaurants that were auditioning, desperately, to get into your drawer, because the drawer was the only algorithm that mattered. What replaced all of that was a platform. And a platform has no memory. A platform doesn’t know you. A platform doesn’t care whether your food is hot. A platform wants another order.

ALSO READ: The Breakup Scene from “You’ve Got Mail” was Filmed at this Forgotten UWS Haunt

Now I sit watching a dot crawl across a map. I watch it idle at a red light for five minutes, then another five. The app would like me to know that everything is fine. The food arrives cold, on the hallway floor. Delivery fee. Service fee. Convenience fee — the cruelest invention. And then, before I’ve even seen what I ordered: How much would you like to tip? For what, exactly? For the floor? For the cold?

My drawer still exists. It holds silverware now, like every other schmuck in every other city who never knew any better.

Anyway — I have to go. My Uber is four minutes away. Did I ever tell you how cabs used to be?

Have a news tip? Send it to us here!