
NYC Dept of Health
The city’s Health Department has shut down an Upper West Side bar after inspectors found signs of rats, mice and flies inside, along with a handful of other sanitary problems that added up to well past the threshold for a failing grade.
Advertisement
The closure hit Gebhard’s Beer Culture at 228 West 72nd Street, between West End Avenue and Broadway, following an inspection on Tuesday, November 17. The bar, which is popular for its extensive beer list, was hit with seven sanitary violations and 44 points in all.In the Health Department’s system, inspectors add points for each violation they find, so a lower score is better. A score of 0 to 13 earns an A, 14 to 27 is a B, and 28 or more is a C. That puts Gebhard’s 44 points well past the threshold for the worst grade. A high score doesn’t automatically mean a letter grade gets posted, though. A restaurant can earn an A on its first inspection, but a B or C is only handed out after a follow-up reinspection. A closure is also a separate step from grading. The department has said it closes establishments that pose a risk to public health, whatever their score.
According to inspection results posted by the Health Department, four of the seven violations were highlighted in red. Inspectors found evidence of rats or live rats in the establishment’s food or non-food areas, along with evidence of mice or live mice. They also found filth flies or other nuisance pests, a category the department says includes house flies, blow flies, bottle flies, flesh flies, drain flies, phorid flies and fruit flies. The fourth red-flagged violation was for a food contact surface that wasn’t properly washed, rinsed and sanitized after each use, or after any activity when contamination may have happened.
Advertisement
The other three violations had to do with the space and its equipment. Inspectors wrote that the bar wasn’t free of harborage or conditions conducive to rodents, insects or other pests. They also cited a drainage and plumbing violation. That category covers several possible problems, including a missing back-flow prevention device, equipment or a floor that isn’t draining properly, a sewage disposal system that’s in disrepair, or liquid waste that’s disposed of improperly. The posted results don’t say which of these applied. Finally, a non-food contact surface or piece of equipment was cited because it was made of unacceptable material, wasn’t kept clean, or wasn’t sealed, raised, spaced or movable enough to be cleaned on all sides.It’s not yet clear when Gebhard’s will be allowed to reopen, but we’ve reached out to the bar for comment. Inspection results for any restaurant in the city can be searched on the Health Department’s website.
Have a news tip? Send it to us here!




